Relocation and Change in Results

So, there is a concept going on that if you change your place of residence and relocate to a different city or country then your chart changes as per the co-ordinates of that particular city and that can give you a different result in life. It is almost equivalent to saying that your chart changes by relocating. I just thought about giving my views on it and inviting views of you all.

Example - So, 1st let's understand this concept through an example. So, I was born at Indore, India with a Scorpio Ascendant Chart but if I had been born at Moscow, Russia then I would have had a Libra ascendant chart or if I had been born at some other city/country then I would have had a different ascendant chart as per the co-ordinates of that country. Now, putting the theory into practicality as I understood, it means that if I relocate myself to Moscow, Russia then I will start getting results as a Libra ascendant chart. Likewise, my life/career etc would be much like a Libra ascendant person then and it is much like becoming a Libra ascendant person and my birth chart of Scorpio ascendant will be taking a back-seat after the relocation.

Now, my views -

1. 1st of all, relocations are never forced. They happen due to circumstances in your life. If you are destined to relocate to a different city/country then circumstances will change in such a way that you would have to relocate. I don't think it ever happened that someone checked the co-ordinates and rising sign of a country and decided to relocate. It can be an additional reason for relocating but not foundational reason.

2. I remember that after passing-away of my father in 2009, we shifted back to our home town at Ujjain from Secunderabad but within an year in 2010, we shifted back to Secunderabad as I got a job. So, 2 things are important here. 1st is that both relocations happened due to change of circumstances and 2nd is that we came back to the place where we were destined to be, the same city. It may interest few that even within Secunderabad, we came back to the same locality where we used to reside in 2009.  

3. Then even if you are relocating to a different place then even that relocation is an event which is allowed by your birth chart, dasha and transits. If Lord Krishna was relocated from his place of birth (Mathura) to Nandgaon within one night of his birth then this event would have been in his birth chart itself. Then only he could be taken to a different place. But it doesn't make Nandgaon as his place of birth or takes priority over Mathura.

4. I guess this is what I want to convey here is that just like any other event, your relocation to a different city is based on your chart, dasha and transits. So in no case, the relocated city/country or its co-ordinates or its rising sign can take priority over the birth place. In my view, the relocated city/country will never take priority over your birth place and your birth chart will remain as is.

Then how people start getting different or more positive/negative results after moving to a different place?

5. It is just because of the concept of Desh-Kaal-Paristhiti - https://www.astrosaxena.com/dkpb and https://www.astrosaxena.com/difres . Every different city/country is at different level of development, opportunity or social evolution. So, person is bound to get results of these factors after relocation. Even if someone moves from a town to a bigger city within a country then his life is bound to change as he will have more exposure, opportunities and possibilities for improvement of his life. Likewise, if you move to any country which is more developed or less developed then you are bound to get the results accordingly.

6. So YES, in my considered view, your life can go through a positive or negative change as per the city/country you are relocating but I don't think that it is going to change your birth chart at all. I don't think that ascendant of birth chart should be changed by any means. Your life will still move as per your birth chart, dasha and transits.

Please let me know your opinions.

Thanks,